Unruh Insurance Agency
Lancaster Mutual Insurance Company

Specialty Insurance

In 1895, a few businessmen and community leaders recognized a need for a local insurance company. The idea was to protect local homes and businesses that more established insurance companies wouldn’t write, all while maintaining affordable rates. Thus, Reamstown Mutual was born.

Jump to 2022: Reamstown Mutual changes its name to Lancaster Mutual Insurance Company. While more standard homeowner and mobile home policies became available in 1963, Lancaster Mutual has stayed true to its deep agricultural roots by writing harder-to-place risks in personal, commercial, and farm lines of business.

At Unruh, we’re proud to be able to offer coverage from Lancaster Mutual. To get started with a quote, click the button below.

Lancaster Mutual covers tough to place farm lines of business

Insurance from Lancaster Mutual


Home/Mobile Home



Staying True to Their Roots

From the heart of Lancaster County, Lancaster Mutual continues to provide insurance for those with harder-to-place risks. Whether it’s personal, commercial, or farm lines of business, your hometown insurance company has you covered.

Lancaster Mutual writes policies for hard to place farms.

Looking for a Quote?

Are you looking for coverage for something that other insurers have turned down? Start your better insurance experience with Unruh by contacting us today and we will get started with a quote from Lancaster Mutual. Our services won’t cost you a dime. Plus, we’ll answer any questions you may have along the way. Simple as that.

    Your Name*

    Your Email*


    Address 2





    Best time to reach me

    Date of Birth

    I am interested in:

    Farm InsuranceHome/Mobile Home InsuranceBusiness Insurance

    What Brought You Here Today?

    Additional Notes:

    Stay Up-To-Date On All Things Insurance!

    Downtown Denver

    Downtown Denver

    Unruh Insurance Agency, Inc.
    335 Main Street
    Denver, PA 17517
    P: 717-335-2929 | F: 717-335-2923

    Mon. – Thurs. : 8:30 am – 5:30 pm
    Fri. : 8:30 am – 5:00 pm
    Sat. : 9:00am - 12:00pm
    Shady Maple

    Shady Maple Complex

    Unruh Insurance Agency, Inc.
    1344 Main Street
    East Earl, PA 17519
    P: 877-854-3309 | F: 717-351-5431

    Mon. – Thurs. : 8:30 am – 5:30 pm
    Fri. : 8:30 am – 5:00 pm
    Sat. : Closed
    Skip to content